Rent, Sell, or Save? How To Best Earn on a Second Property

For retirees or those nearing retirement, a second property represents a potential source of financial stability that could help you live comfortably in your golden years. But deciding what to do with it can be tricky. 

Should you rent it out, sell it, or hold onto it for later? Through this blog, we’ll explore how to best earn on a second property, helping you make the decision that aligns with your long-term goals and lifestyle preferences.

Renting Out Your Second Property

Rental income can create a steady cash flow during retirement, making it an attractive option for many. Traditional long-term rentals are often simpler to manage and offer reliable monthly payments, whereas short-term rental platforms like Airbnb demand more effort but often bring higher returns.

Of course, if you opt for something like a short-term rental unit, you will still need to make some changes to the property. Firstly, you can expect to make repairs and upgrades for compliance purposes. Afterward, you’ll need to think about security. 

Hotels use NFC access controls for their spaces, and you might be able to do the same. From there, you’ll need to invest in décor, furnishings, and essentials that make the space welcoming to guests. 

A short-term rental might seem like the easier option, but it’s akin to starting a business and requires a similar upfront investment.

For retirees, physical and financial involvement in any form of rental management should also be considered. Hiring a property manager can help reduce that stress, but it will cut into profits. Depending on your health and priorities, renting out may or may not be the right path.

Selling the Property

Selling offers an immediate financial gain, which could provide liquidity for investments, healthcare, or once-in-a-lifetime experiences. 

It’s a popular choice if the property has appreciated significantly or if maintenance is becoming unmanageable. Many retirees find that simplifying their investments rather than juggling multiple properties allows them to focus more on enjoying life. 

However, taking the time to calculate capital gains taxes and balance the potential for future market growth will be an essential part of this decision.

Keeping It in Your Back Pocket

Sometimes, holding onto a second property is the smartest choice. Real estate often increases in value over time, offering wealth-building potential for heirs or yourself. 

Additionally, keeping the property could provide a fallback plan if your future living needs change. Retaining it comes with costs, like upkeep and taxes, but if you’re certain about leaving a legacy or keeping family-oriented vacation space available, this path might suit you best.

Making the Right Choice for You

Every option has its merits and challenges, but the answer to how to best earn on a second property depends on your unique situation. For retirees, comfort, financial stability, and future family needs matter most. 

Each of these paths offers a way to align your property with the retirement you’ve envisioned. Whether that means a steady income, a full cash-out, or holding onto a valued asset, the choice is yours to make.

3 Ways a Mortgage Beats Renting for Aspiring DIY’ers

If your urge to undo and improve is strong enough, you might be able to put that energy to positive use by owning your home instead of renting. Besides the satisfaction you get from doing-it-yourself, you will probably come out financially ahead.

You Don’t Need Permission

Renters must have permission from their landlords or property managers to make changes to the home, even for the smallest improvements. They may balk at letting tenants paint, change faucets, replace faucets, or even have carpets cleaned.

Unless there’s a homeowner association involved, homeowners have complete control over their property. If they want brightly colored walls or flooring, the choice is theirs. They can remodel to the extent their budgets and abilities allow, something that few, if any, landlords will allow.

The two major issues that keep landlords from allowing tenant changes include skepticism about the tenant’s qualifications as a do-it-yourselfer and the budget. Even without the labor included, even the simplest home remodeling projects cost money.

Homeowners Can Borrow the Money

The first step in buying a home is to meet with the lender will calculate the monthly payment based on the down payment and interest rate. Mortgage payments are almost always lower than monthly rent rates. The interest rates for primary home loans are usually the lowest available for any kind of borrowing.

Home values appreciate over time and you can turn the equity into a home equity line of credit (HELOC) to fund other home improvement projects that will add value. HELOCs also carry lower interest rates than other kinds of consumer loans, especially compared to credit card interest rates.

Home Improvements Add Value

By putting your do-it-yourself skills to good use, you add value to a property. How much depends on the project and the demand for the improvement. Few projects return 100 percent of the retail cost, but when you contribute the labor, you will realize a net gain.

People who flip houses make substantial amounts of money improving homes and reselling them when finished. When going this route, research which improvements are in demand in your area. Giving home buyers what they want will enhance the value of your work and possibly speed the sale.

Anyone who enjoys home improvement projects and has the do-it-yourself skills to make the work profitable has the advantage as a homeowner. For them, a mortgage is definitely better than a rent payment.

Investing Insight: Pros And Cons Of Condos Vs Homes

If you're thinking about purchasing a condominium unit or a home then there are a number of differences that you should be aware of before making your decision. 

You need to understand what a condominium actually is and how it differs from an apartment or home for starters. There are a number of personal and financial considerations that can tip the scale in favor (and against) condo ownership, so let's get started.

Condo Pros And Cons

The first upside that a lot of consumers appreciate about owning a condo is that their mortgage payments are far more manageable. 

Even with a 30-year home mortgage you could be talking about monthly mortgage payments in the thousands, which would seldom be the case with a condo in most areas.

With a condo you also don't have to worry about landscaping and trash collection as you normally would with a home. Those kinds of services are usually covered by the condo association and taken care of with your monthly condo assessments. 





With both condos and homes you may pay property taxes. A lot of people might also have a problem with all of the condo association's rules - like what you're allowed to renovate in your unit or the kinds of pets that you're allowed to have in your condo unit.

On the plus side condo ownership can mean an attractive urban unit in the heart of the city at relatively little monthly expense in terms of mortgage payments and biannual property taxes.

Pros Of Home Ownership

The first pro with a home is that there's usually much more space for you to entertain your guests and do what you like. 

You can have as many pets as you want without worrying about condo association rules, and you can have guests stay into the wee hours of the early morning. You'll have more indoor space too with most homes. Any upgrades you make will increase your curb appeal and likely home re-sale value as well.

Cons Of Home Ownership

The downside is that, although you'll have fewer rules to negotiate, you'll have to maintain your own lawn unless you go with a lawn service. 

You might also pay more on a monthly basis as far as mortgage payments or taxes go. It's possible your home could depreciate in value over the lifetime of your investment.

The amount that you're willing to pay towards your mortgage and property taxes, the amount of independence that you need, and the kinds of opportunities in your area will likely determine whether you become a condo or home owner. 

Checking in with real estate professionals, like those at RE/MAX Associates San Antonio, can make the decision easier. If you're still struggling, though, remember that a condo comes with rules and monthly assessments. 

Home ownership, on the other hand, likely means more maintenance but the chance to make a healthier profit at closing when you go to sell and independence until you go to do so.